Understanding and Improving Decision-making in Pneumonia with Informatics
Project Number1IK2HX001908-01A2
Contact PI/Project LeaderJONES, BARBARA ELLEN
Awardee OrganizationVA SALT LAKE CITY HEALTHCARE SYSTEM
Description
Abstract Text
Introduction: This proposal aims to understand and improve the care of Veterans treated for pneumonia
through informatics.
Background: Pneumonia is the most common infectious cause of death in the United States, with an
estimated 50,000 deaths and $8-10 billion in costs annually.12 Twenty-five thousand Veterans are seen per
year in the Emergency Department, and 20,000 are hospitalized.13 Risk adjusted 30-day mortality rates range
among VA facilities from 11% to 18%. The resources utilized for pneumonia also vary widely, with the cost of
hospital care estimated at up to 25 times that of outpatient care.20 To improve the standard of pneumonia care,
intense research and quality improvement efforts have been focused upon establishing evidence-based
practice guidelines for pneumonia that represent a consensus of research and opinions generated from our
best academic hospitals and pneumonia experts. However, we continue to see variation in both management
and outcomes across the VA as in other systems, suggesting that guidelines may be difficult to apply to real
practice. The recent advancement of our electronic health record allows us to measure actual practice at both
the population and the individual level. By studying variation in triage and antibiotic decisions for patients with
pneumonia, we can learn from our own population to generate evidence that includes the previously
underrepresented patients, settings and scenarios, bringing it closer to real practice.
Career Aims: My career goals are to: 1) Develop skills in advanced population analytics, 2) Gain a foundation
in behavioral sciences, and 3) Develop a deeper understanding in informatics.
Research Aims: My research aims build toward my career aims: (1) Examine sources of variation in triage
and antibiotic selection decisions for pneumonia across VA emergency departments. (2) Characterize the
cognitive processes influencing decision-making in pneumonia among providers at emergency departments
demonstrating variation in decision-making. (3) Design and test an informatics tool that supports decision-
making, integrates with workflow, and allows us to learn from clinical experience.
Methods: Aim 1 A. will develop and test models of practice variation for triage and antibiotic selection and b.
will identify emergency departments with high and low decision-making thresholds across the VA system. Aim
2 will use mixed methods to characterize the cognitive process of clinical reasoning and contextual influences
impact decision-making through interviews with providers. Aim 3 will utilize a real-time informatics tool to test
current best practice recommendations against physician decisions by providing physicians the opportunity to
disagree with any recommendations, and collect information on reasons for disagreement.
Impact: This work will directly inform the development of informatics tools for pneumonia for the VA.
Ultimately, while my clinical interest is in pneumonia, the skills I develop will be applied to many clinical
problems in medicine where decision-making occurs in the setting of uncertainty.
Public Health Relevance Statement
Pneumonia is a common but challenging disease, requiring providers to make difficult decisions
under uncertainty in diagnosis, etiology, and consequences. Implementation of practice
guidelines based upon traditional evidence-based medicine has made overall improvements in
care, but this approach fails to account for the complexity in decision-making at the individual
level for many clinical scenarios. The electronic health record within the VA provides a unique
opportunity to build a research foundation that learns through the experience of the population,
individuals, and also at the point of care using informatics tools. My research integrates big
data, interviews with providers, and an informatics tool to generate evidence and cognitive
support that are relevant to more clinical environments and patients. This will ultimately enhance
decision-making and lead to better, more individualized care for patients.
NIH Spending Category
No NIH Spending Category available.
Project Terms
Accident and Emergency departmentAdoptedAmbulatory CareAntibioticsAreaAthleticBackBehavioral SciencesBig DataBiological ModelsCaringCause of DeathCessation of lifeClinicalCognitiveConsciousConsensusCritical CareDecision MakingDevelopmentDiagnosisDiseaseElectronic Health RecordEnvironmentEtiologyEvidence Based MedicineFeedbackFeedsFoundationsGoalsGuidelinesHealth PersonnelHealth ServicesHealth Services ResearchHealthcareHealthcare SystemsHospital CostsHospitalsIndividualInfectionInformaticsInterviewJudgmentLeadLearningMeasuresMedicineMethodsMicrobiologyModelingOutcomePatient-Focused OutcomesPatientsPatternPhilosophyPhysiciansPneumoniaPopulationPractice GuidelinesProviderRecommendationResearchResearch MethodologyResearch PersonnelResourcesRiskRuralSamplingSourceSystemTestingTimeTriageUncertaintyUnited StatesVariantVeteransWorkbasecareercognitive processcostdesignevidence baseevidence based guidelinesexperiencefeedingimprovedimproved outcomeindividual patientinterestlearning progressionmortalitypatient populationpersonalized carepersonalized decisionpoint of careskillssuccesssupport toolstheoriestool
No Sub Projects information available for 1IK2HX001908-01A2
Publications
Publications are associated with projects, but cannot be identified with any particular year of the project or fiscal year of funding. This is due to the continuous and cumulative nature of knowledge generation across the life of a project and the sometimes long and variable publishing timeline. Similarly, for multi-component projects, publications are associated with the parent core project and not with individual sub-projects.
No Publications available for 1IK2HX001908-01A2
Patents
No Patents information available for 1IK2HX001908-01A2
Outcomes
The Project Outcomes shown here are displayed verbatim as submitted by the Principal Investigator (PI) for this award. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed are those of the PI and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Institutes of Health. NIH has not endorsed the content below.
No Outcomes available for 1IK2HX001908-01A2
Clinical Studies
No Clinical Studies information available for 1IK2HX001908-01A2
News and More
Related News Releases
No news release information available for 1IK2HX001908-01A2
History
No Historical information available for 1IK2HX001908-01A2
Similar Projects
No Similar Projects information available for 1IK2HX001908-01A2