Patient Navigation 2.0: Addressing the Challenge of Scaling Navigation through Checklist-based Implementation
Project Number5R01CA163830-11
Contact PI/Project LeaderSIMON, MELISSA A.
Awardee OrganizationNORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY AT CHICAGO
Description
Abstract Text
Through the work of a well-established research partnership among the Chinese American Service League
(CASL), Mercy Hospital & Medical Center (Mercy), and Northwestern University (NU), our team completed a trial
evaluating a one-on-one patient navigation (PN) intervention for breast and cervical cancer tailored to Chicago’s
Chinatown. Our completed trial and others have demonstrated that PN is effective in improving consistency of
cancer care and addressing Social Determinants of Health (SDoH) among underserved populations.
Unfortunately, current standard one-on-one PN is difficult to scale and sustain without intensive financial
resources, which limits one-on-one cancer PN to a temporary “Band-Aid” for fragmented healthcare systems.
We have an opportunity to apply our team’s lessons learned from our completed PN trial in order to create a
paradigm shift in PN to produce systems change in cancer care delivery to meet the needs of underserved
populations. To do so, we propose a learning health system PN 2.0 Checklist implementation strategy that
scales implementation of PN across cancers and builds a sustainable team-based checklist that will support
coordination and integration of SDoH-related efforts across community oncology and community social service
settings. In Aim 1, we will employ a design-thinking framework of co-creation and iterative prototyping to develop
the PN 2.0 Checklist, transforming one-on-one PN into a learning health system PN approach centered around
a team-based checklist that leverages the PN evidence base and active participation of community oncology
and community social service stakeholders. In Aim 2, through a Hybrid Type 2 randomized effectiveness-
implementation pragmatic trial, we will compare the effectiveness (non-inferiority) of the PN 2.0 Checklist
relative to one-on-one PN in resolving SDoH barriers and increasing patient receipt of clinical cancer preventive
services. N=600 Chinese adults recruited from Chicago’s Chinatown will be randomized to standard one-on-one
cancer PN (control) or cancer PN 2.0 Checklist (intervention). The primary outcome is an adjusted, composite
proportion of SDoH barriers resolved and completion of U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommended
cancer-related screenings, behavioral counseling, and immunizations, collected via chart review and patient
surveys. We will explore the effect of the PN 2.0 Checklist on organizational change and patient assessment of
care team quality using pre/post surveys. Secondary outcomes include time to diagnostic resolution and time to
treatment initiation. In Aim 3, we will use the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR) and
mixed-methods (process evaluation, qualitative interviews, cost analysis) to evaluate the implementation of the
learning health system PN 2.0 Checklist strategy. Results will have important implications for implementation,
sustainability, and scaling of PN in community oncology settings where medically underserved U.S. immigrant
populations, such as linguistically isolated Chinese, receive the bulk of their cancer care.
Public Health Relevance Statement
PROJECT NARRATIVE
Cancer patient navigation (PN) is an effective strategy for resolving patient barriers to care and improving
completion and consistency of cancer screening, follow-up of abnormal findings, and treatment initiation.
However, as the current standard one-on-one PN model is challenging to scale across cancers and economically
difficult to sustain, we propose to convert one-on-one PN into a learning health system “PN 2.0 Checklist” that
will help coordinate navigation workflow and integrate clinical team members with community/local resources.
We will conduct a pragmatic, randomized trial to test whether this checklist strategy is as effective as one-on-
one PN in addressing patients’ social determinants of health and recommended cancer-related screenings,
behavioral counseling, and immunizations.
NIH Spending Category
No NIH Spending Category available.
Project Terms
AccountabilityAddressAdultAdvisory CommitteesAreaBehavioralCancer PatientCaringChicagoChineseChinese AmericanClimateClinicalCollaborationsCommunitiesCommunity Clinical Oncology ProgramCommunity HealthCommunity ParticipationConsolidated Framework for Implementation ResearchCost AnalysisCounselingDiagnosticFundingHealthHealth systemHealthcare SystemsHospitalsHuman PapillomavirusHybridsImmigrantImmigrant communityImmunizationInstitutionInterventionInterviewLearningLinguisticsMalignant Breast NeoplasmMalignant NeoplasmsMalignant neoplasm of cervix uteriMammographic screeningMedical centerMethodsMidwestern United StatesModelingOrganizational ChangeOrganizational CultureParticipantPatientsPopulationPreventive serviceRandomizedRecommendationResearchResearch PersonnelResolutionResourcesScreening for cancerScreening procedureService settingServicesSocial WorkSurveysSystemTestingThinkingTimeUnderserved PopulationUnited States Preventative Services Task ForceUniversitiesWorkbarrier to carecancer carecare deliverycompare effectivenessdesigneffectiveness/implementation trialevidence basefollow-upimplementation evaluationimplementation strategyimplementation/effectivenessimprovedmedically underservedmedically underserved populationmemberorganizational readinessparticipant enrollmentpatient navigationpatient-level barrierspaymentpost interventionpragmatic trialprimary outcomeprocess evaluationprogramsprototyperandomized trialrecruitsafety netscreeningsecondary outcomesocialsocial health determinantssocial service provider
No Sub Projects information available for 5R01CA163830-11
Publications
Publications are associated with projects, but cannot be identified with any particular year of the project or fiscal year of funding. This is due to the continuous and cumulative nature of knowledge generation across the life of a project and the sometimes long and variable publishing timeline. Similarly, for multi-component projects, publications are associated with the parent core project and not with individual sub-projects.
No Publications available for 5R01CA163830-11
Patents
No Patents information available for 5R01CA163830-11
Outcomes
The Project Outcomes shown here are displayed verbatim as submitted by the Principal Investigator (PI) for this award. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed are those of the PI and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Institutes of Health. NIH has not endorsed the content below.
No Outcomes available for 5R01CA163830-11
Clinical Studies
No Clinical Studies information available for 5R01CA163830-11
News and More
Related News Releases
No news release information available for 5R01CA163830-11
History
No Historical information available for 5R01CA163830-11
Similar Projects
No Similar Projects information available for 5R01CA163830-11